Call Today For Your Free Case Strategy Session. (248) 419-6133

 Satawa Law, PLLC

What Makes a Child Forensic Interview Reliable?

  • By: Mark Satawa, Esq.

A child forensic interviewer, speaking with a child in a calm, child-friendly interview roomIn this article, you can discover…

  • What happens during a child forensic interview, and who is qualified to conduct one.
  • Signs forensic interviewers look for that a child may have been coached or manipulated.
  • Whether a forensic interview can be challenged in court, and the role of a defense attorney.

What Is A Child Forensic Interview, And Who Is Qualified To Conduct One?

Child forensic interviews are conducted by trained interviewers (many of whom are social workers) at child advocacy centers after suspicions of physical abuse, neglect, or sexual abuse have arisen. These interviews exist because prosecutors and law enforcement, over time, began to realize how incredibly difficult it was to interview a child and get accurate, objective, and reliable information about what did or did not happen. 

One reason for this is that children are extremely susceptible to suggestion, significantly more so than adults. In fact, there are ample studies that show simply asking a child the same question more than one time is suggestive to the child. 

For example, if a mother asks a child, “Did Daddy hit you?” and the child says “No”, if the mother asks the child that same question a second time, a third time, and a fourth time, this sends a message to the child that the initial answer they gave was wrong. I.e., “No” must have been the wrong answer, or else Mom wouldn’t continue to ask me that question. 

So forensic interviews are meant to remove any and all bias, suggestibility, and influence that might amend or change (or “plant”) a child’s memory. The goal of the forensic interview is to get the child to talk about what happened to them based on their personal knowledge, not because a parent asked them questions or told them something, and not because of anything they saw on TV or on their phone. 

The interviews are conducted in a comfortable room with couches and stuffed animals by trained forensic interviewers who must follow very specific rules. They don’t suggest topics, they ask open-ended questions, they don’t repeat the same questions, and they use age-appropriate language. 

These guidelines are part of the Forensic Interviewing Protocol that is published by the Governor’s Task Force on Forensic Interviewing in the State of Michigan. 

What Signs During A Forensic Interview May Indicate That A Child Was Influenced Or Subjected To Suggestive Questioning?

During the interview, common red flags include a child using words or language that are not age-appropriate, as memory is directly tied to linguistic development. For example, if a six-year-old uses the word “ominous”, that’s a probable red flag, whereas a 14-year-old using the word “ominous” may not be. 

Next, interviewers will look for “sensory details”. True reports tend to have quite a bit of detail regarding temperature, smells, colors, what clothing was worn, the weather, etc. When a report is based on something that someone told the child to say, those details tend to be absent. 

Finally, forensic interviewers will look to see if a child’s story changes a bit with each retelling. Many people assume that a true story will stay entirely consistent. In fact, a true story is likely to add or omit small details with each retelling, or change some small facts (such as it being 9 o’clock versus 10 o’clock when the incident occurred). 

In contrast, telling the same story almost word-for-word repeatedly is a red flag that the story may be the result of suggestion or implanted memories. All of these red flags are signs that a forensic interviewer will be on the lookout for as they speak with the child.  

How Do Defense Attorneys Evaluate Child Forensic Interviews During A Michigan Criminal Case?

Within the last several years, more counties in Michigan have begun recording forensic interviews. For the longest time, law enforcement, prosecutors, and forensic interviewers fought the idea that forensic interviews should be recorded. 

But recordings of forensic interviews help the child, and law enforcement prosecute a case, far more than not recording them. For example, if the interview is recorded, this preserves the child’s answers and keeps them from having to endure further interviews should the prosecutor investigating the case change. 

Next, the recorded interview is fixed and in Michigan subject to a statute and strong, protective orders. A defense attorney, for example, can request a copy, but that cannot make a copy of their own. This minimizes the risk of the recording being manipulated or edited. 

Your defense attorney can and should review a copy of that forensic interview with you. In my own career, I have seen and reviewed hundreds of these interviews. But while I know all the rules and the red flags to watch for, and know everything that goes into a strong, helpful interview, nothing takes the place of consulting with an expert forensic psychologist for the defense, trained in forensic interviewing. Thus, it is very important for the interview to be reviewed, not only by your lawyer, but by a forensic psychologist who is an expert in child psychology, child memory, and child linguistics. 

Can The Methods Used During A Forensic Interview Be Challenged In Court?

Yes, once the forensic interview has been reviewed by you and your attorney and by a forensic psychologist, if your attorney has concerns about the reliability of the interview, it can be challenged in court.

In this context, reliability breaks down into two sub-issues:

  1. Were the guidelines and parameters of the forensic interviewing protocol followed carefully and consistently?
  2. Next, is the child testifying from personal knowledge, or is the child testifying from susceptibility or suggested memory?

Either of these issues would be raised through a motion challenging the child’s ability to testify from personal knowledge. If the motion is granted, this would lead to an evidentiary hearing where the forensic interviewer (along with anyone else who spoke to the child before the forensic interview) would be cross-examined. 

Next, your attorney may conduct a trial run in front of a judge, asking the child questions they would not know the answer to (such as the name of the attorney’s dog) to determine if the child will simply make up an answer instead of saying, “I don’t know”. This can help determine if the child is truly competent to give accurate, reliable testimony about the alleged abuse. 

This entire process also helps your attorney gather valuable insights into the prosecutor’s case and better plan for trial and for the cross-examination of witnesses.

Still Have Questions? Ready To Get Started?

For more information on Michigan child abuse defense lawyer, an initial consultation is your next best step. Get the information and legal answers you are seeking by calling (248) 419-6133 today.