Call Today For Your Free Case Strategy Session. (248) 419-6133
In this article, you can discover…
Yes, and, in fact, this is frequently the case. Most children’s hospitals have a position known as a Child Abuse Pediatrician (CAP), who is the head of the “Child Protection Team.” And when a medical professional such as a CAP – trained to identify signs of child abuse – is asked by investigators to look for signs of child abuse, they will likely find them, no matter the circumstances of the child’s injuries.
The moment a CAP provides their opinion that abuse has occurred, every other doctor in that hospital, from the neurologist to the radiologist, will fall into line and agree with that opinion. And when a child abuse case goes to trial, frequently the CAP will be the only medical expert the prosecution calls to testify. So, yes, a single doctor’s opinion can absolutely cause child abuse charges to be filed.
As much as we would like to believe that medicine and science are always exact and clear, they’re not. Science and medicine are constantly evolving, and making new discoveries every day. Remember how for decades doctors told us that ulcers were caused by stress? Wrong, as proven by two doctors in Australia that discovered ulcers are caused by a bacteria. This is why someone with a torn tendon can be told by medical specialists that they simply have a sprained ankle. Misdiagnoses happen all the time.
What’s more, radiology is one of the most subjective bodies of study that exist in medicine. In essence, when you look at an X-ray or an MRI, you are reading and trying to interpret shadows and tiny imperfections in bone and tissue.
Multiple blind studies have been done in which radiologists have been shown the same image without any additional information, and have reached wildly different conclusions. The same is true when radiologists try to date injuries, determine how long ago a fracture occurred, and/or how long it has been healing.
Most people have personal stories or stories from family members who spent months or years trying to have an ailment diagnosed, only to run into difficulties, inaccurate diagnoses, and disagreements between specialists as symptoms persisted or got worse.
If doctors can disagree in a non-courtroom setting, why do we assume that medical opinions should be infallible in court? The reality is that they are not, and must be questioned.
Yes, and this can be an important part of helping a jury to see that they have reason to doubt the prosecution’s claims and witnesses’ opinions.
When a physician is providing their opinion as to whether abuse has occurred, there is no objective test or gold standard that can be applied. In other areas of medicine, such as oncology, standards are much clearer. A lump either exists or it does not. It is biopsied, and the results show that it is either cancerous or it is not. The doctor’s initial diagnosis is either confirmed or refuted by the biopsy. This allows not only a gold standard in terms of confirming the diagnosis, it allows the doctor to improve their diagnostic skills through the use of this confirmatory testing.
In cases of suspected child abuse, no such gold standard or confirmatory test exists. a physician will notice conditions such as subdural hematoma, retinal hemorrhaging, edema, and neurologic distress and conclude that the child was abused. But by what standard are they providing this opinion? They are providing this opinion based solely on their own anecdotal experience.
That is correct, the standard is nothing more than prior opinions on suspected abuse cases the physician has seen. The last time I saw this set of injuries (subdural hematoma, retinal hemorrhaging, and neurological compromise), I diagnosed abuse. Now I see the same set of injuries, so this case must be abuse too. The fact that this is based on complete speculation and circular reasoning could not be more obvious.
But in every case, an opinion of abuse may be incorrect, may be based on false assumptions, or may be based on unreliable witness testimony. In other words, there is no objective medical test or gold standard to determine if injuries were caused by abuse. This is why getting a second expert medical opinion is important; this opinion can be presented during a trial and can be instrumental in helping a jury to see that the prosecution has not proven their case against you beyond a reasonable doubt.
Depending on the circumstances of your case, your attorney may bring in a neuroradiologist, a neurologist, a biomechanical engineer, an orthopedic surgeon, or an entirely different expert to testify about the range of causes possible for a given injury. The simpler and more common-sense a medical explanation is, the more likely it will resonate with a jury.
An experienced criminal defense attorney will know enough about the science and medicine behind child abuse allegations to understand the scientific underpinnings of a strong case versus a weak case.
While your lawyer is not a doctor, an experienced attorney will be able to see flaws in the prosecution’s expert’s opinion, explain to a jury the lack of certainty surrounding the origin of certain injuries, and how subjective radiology readings can be.
Your lawyer must also be experienced enough to know his/her limitations – to understand that they need to hire, consult with, call defense expert witnesses to explain these nuances simply and rationally to a jury. A good lawyer will not only hire an expert, but they’ll hire the right expert who understands the controversies in their field to address the prosecution’s claims. This can be absolutely pivotal in court and help significantly strengthen your defense.
For more information on expert opinions and Michigan child abuse allegations, an initial consultation is your next best step. Get the information and legal answers you are seeking by calling (248) 419-6133 today.