Satawa Law, PLLC. recently has won another Title IX hearing, as the office for title 9 and institutional equity at University in Western Michigan “unanimously determined that the preponderance of evidence does not support a finding that the responded engaged in sexual assault or sexual harassment.”Read More

Call Today For Your Free Case Strategy Session. (248) 419-6133

 Satawa Law, PLLC

Online Sting Operations in Michigan: What You Didn’t Know Could Be Illegal

  • By: Mark Satawa, Esq.

Two hands protecting a paper cutout of a family on a red background.In this article, you can discover…

  • How online sting operations work in Michigan.
  • What happens if you genuinely believe you were talking with an adult?
  • Whether law enforcement can intentionally escalate online conversations.

How Do Online Sting Operations Work Under Michigan’s Internet Solicitation Laws?

Agents involved in online sting operations have extensive training in technology and in how to communicate, talk, and text/type like a minor. They get specialized training, practice and hone these technical and communication skills for quite a while, and then go to sites, platforms, and apps where they are likely to find someone predisposed to wanting to talk to an adult (or young adult/teenager) about sex.

The operators then pose as a teenager and wait for someone to engage with them. They constantly nudge and push conversations along until the adult begins talking openly about sex, and eventually about meeting the (presumed) minor in person, whether in public, at a hotel, or at the adult’s home.

What If I Genuinely Believed The Person I Was Talking To Online Was An Adult?

If you believed you were talking to a fellow adult, you have not committed a crime, as it is only a crime to discuss sex and sexual activity with someone you know or have reason to believe (or should have known) to be under 18.

However, this is a nuanced, factual dispute that will absolutely require a good, experienced criminal defense lawyer to prove. Some adults roleplay age-related fantasies with other adults, and the forensic details of chat logs, emails, and messages will be combed through by your attorney to help determine if you genuinely believed you were simply roleplaying with someone who was 18 years old or above.

Can Law Enforcement Engaged In Sting Operations Escalate Conversations To Suggest Criminal Activity Or Intent?

To an extent, yes. Law enforcement is allowed to lie and does lie in the process of investigating and prosecuting sex-based internet/cyber crimes, and an officer representing themselves as a minor online is not breaking any laws.

Officers are also allowed to escalate conversations by introducing sexual topics in an attempt to nudge you into discussing sex with someone you may believe to be a minor.

Having said that, it is illegal for Michigan law enforcement to induce you to engage in criminal activity that you would not otherwise have committed. This is known as entrapment.

In order to prove entrapment, your attorney must establish that it was the officer’s conduct that caused you to commit a crime, and not your own predisposition. This requires proof that the police induced an otherwise law abiding individual to commit a crime that they otherwise would not have committed. Entrapment occurs if the police engage in impermissible conduct inducing a law abiding person to commit a crime, or if conduct is so reprehensible it cannot be tolerated. For example, if the officer engaged in harassment, threats, or fraud.

Michigan’s test for entrapment is an objective test, it does not focus on the subjective state of mind of the individual defendant involved in the investigation. Entrapment is a legal question decided by a judge, and does not get submitted to a jury in state criminal charges in Michigan. You will have to prove that you are a law-abiding person who would not have committed the crime had the police not induced you or persuaded you to do so. The burden of proof is on the defendant to prove entrapment by a preponderance of evidence, meaning at least a 51% likelihood that entrapment occurred.

Is It Illegal To Simply Chat Online If No Actual Meeting Occurs?

Yes. If you discuss sex or sexual topics online with someone you believe (or should have known) to be under the age of 18, you have already committed a crime, even if you never meet up with this person in real life. That crime is known as child sexually abusive activity.

Law enforcement conducting sting operations will frequently encourage or suggest an I person meeting, as this can be strong evidence of an intent to meet up with a minor for sexual activity. Still, a real-life meeting is not necessary for a conviction For crimes like child sexually abusive activity, and you can be convicted of a crime simply for chatting online.

Still Have Questions? Ready To Get Started?

For more information on online sting operations in Michigan, an initial consultation is your next best step. Get the information and legal answers you are seeking by calling (248) 419-6133 today.